Opportunities and Challenges of 2026

The accompanying chart from Jeffrey Hirsch of Almanac Trader shows the expected seasonal price pattern for the S&P 500. As with any seasonality analysis, direction is more important than the magnitude of the move. If history is any guide, expect a volatile year until October, followed by a rally into year-end.
 

I agree with the broad strokes of the seasonality analysis, and the pattern forms the base case of my S&P 500 market expectations for 2026.
 

 

But I still have questions for the market, and here are the opportunities and challenges for investors in the new year.
 

 

The K-Shaped Recovery Question

Coming into the new year, investors may be in for an upside economic surprise from the consumer because of a tax refund-driven spending surge from the stimulus effects of the OBBB Act.
 

 

The deficits from the OBBB Act are all front-loaded and their effects will begin to be seen in 2026. The tax cut provisions of the OBBB Act is designed to make capex great again and raise household disposable income in the middle and high income groups.
 

 

From a hopeful perspective, the December Dallas Fed Manufacturing Survey is showing signs of a turnaround in business conditions. Here are some sample comments among reports of gloom:

  • This past quarter we have experienced 20 percent growth over last year.
  • Hope has arrived….we’re actually [experiencing] increasing gross revenue and improving margins for the first time in a very long time.

On the other hand, the restart in student loan payments, cuts in SNAP, Medicaid and the likely expiry of ACA health insurance subsidies will pressure households, especially in the lower income groups. These provisions will exacerbate the effects of the K-shaped expansion, but unleash a wave of capital and consumer spending, among the middle and high-end consumers.

 

The question for investors is whether the market will focus on the positive effects of the tax refunds on the upper-end consumer, but the income drag effects on the balance sheet of middle and low-end households.
 

 

Fed Policy and the Bond Market

What about Fed policy? Coming into 2026, the market expects the Fed to cut rates to about the 3% level, though the minutes of the December FOMC meeting  indicate that the Fed  could be on  hold for some time. With inflation running at between 2% and 3%, that makes for a highly stimulative monetary policy.
 

 

Notwithstanding any expectations of political interference at the Fed, the December Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) shows the upper end of unemployment expectations at 4.4%. With the job market already showing signs of weakness and the somewhat flawed November unemployment rate at 4.6%, the bar for cutting rates is very low. I therefore expect a dovish tilt to Fed policy in early 2026.
 

 

The bond market is already reacting to the dovish scenario by steepening the yield curve.

 

How will the stock market react? The knee-jerk bearish scenario is a bear steepening that pushes up the 10-year Treasury yield and rattles stock prices. The bullish narrative is the Fed runs a hot economy that grows above potential, short rates are low and the U.S. Treasury has already signaled that its issuance will be tilted toward T-Bills instead of coupon instruments. This policy combination leads to a virtuous cycle of strong growth and lower-than-expected deficits, which sparks a bond market rally.
 

 

 

The Valuation Question

In addition, equity valuations aren’t cheap. The S&P 500 is trading at a forward P/E of 22. Excluding Big Tech, it’s trading at a forward P/E of 20, which isn’t exactly cheap. Looking globally, regional forward P/E valuations are also extended relative to their own history.
 

 

While P/E ratios matter little in the short run, the accompanying chart shows the history of the S&P 500 at elevated forward P/E valuations.
 

 

Elevated P/E ratios means that for stock prices to advance, rising earnings will have to do most of the heavy lifting and investors can’t depend on P/E expansion as a source of returns. Setting aside the debate about whether AI stocks are in a bubble, analysis from BCA Research showed non-TMT (Tech/Media/Telecom) sales growth was flat in Q3, but EBITDA rose 5% in Q3 despite tariff headwinds. Translation: margin expansion.
 

 

The key question for investors is whether margin expansion will continue.
 

 

War and Peace

Peering into 2026, investors will also have to consider the geopolitical wildcards of the breakouts in war and peace.

 

First, there is a significant possibility that peace, or at least a ceasefire and frozen conflict, may emerge out of the Russo-Ukraine War. Under such a scenario, Russian oil exports would no longer be sanctioned, which would depress oil prices. Lower oil prices would also interfere with Treasury Bessent’s 3-3-3 economic plan of 3% GDP growth, a budget deficit of 3% of GDP and an increase in domestic oil production of 3 million barrels per day.

 

Much of the macro outcome depends on the terms of any peace or ceasefire agreement. The cessation of hostilities could open the door to an enormous reconstruction effort in Ukraine. It would be a seismic shift in equity, credit and foreign exchange markets that could dwarf the effects of German reunification, depending on how reconstruction is financed.

 

On the other hand, the war drums are beating as U.S. forces threaten Venezuela. If the U.S. were to invade, there is also a significant possibility that its military becomes bogged down in a guerilla war quagmire right on America’s doorstep. Venezuelan oil production would fall or be curtailed and put upward pressure on oil prices and inflation.

 

Similarly, open war with Venezuela would depend on how it’s resolved and whether the U.S. can win the peace. Take two examples. The U.S. won the war with its Iraqi invasion but lost the peace as the region remains unstable. On the other hand, America lost the war in Vietnam but ultimately won the peace, as Americans and American businesses are welcomed with open arms today.

 

Pick your poison.
 

 

 

A Bullish Trend

Notwithstanding the geopolitical risks, my models are bullish, therefore I am bullish on equities going into 2026.

 

Global breadth is strong. It is said that there is nothing more bullish than a new high, and the S&P 500 recently made a fresh all-time high, and so did European markets. As well, commodity prices are showing signs of strength, which is a sign of a cyclical rebound.
 

 

That said, the macro backdrop of easy monetary and fiscal policy argues for a rotation into cyclical stocks.
 

 

I am also seeing evidence of a rotation from growth to value across the board. Value stocks are leading the way across all market cap bands and internationally. As well, the decision by Time Magazine to name the Person of the Year as the Architects of AI is a classic case of a contrarian magazine cover indicator that the best times are over for U.S. megacap growth stocks.
 

 

In conclusion, U.S. equity investors face key challenges posed by fiscal and monetary policy, as well as valuation headwinds. However, global equity breadth remains supportive of the bull case. I favour cyclicals and value stocks as sources of outperformance in 2026.

 

3 thoughts on “Opportunities and Challenges of 2026

  1. Venezuela oil is coming to the global market. A new wild card. But this year might be a year of rotation to certain extent.

    1. I’m inclined to stay with the barbell for the time being. Diversification reduces risk.

Comments are closed.